New Hampshire murder mystery resolved after nearly 50 years

 November 27, 2025

A haunting crime from 1975 in Concord, New Hampshire, has at last found its answer, unmasking a killer who slipped through the cracks of justice for far too long.

The case of Judith Lord, a 22-year-old mother found strangled in her apartment, has been solved with the identification of her neighbor, Ernest Theodore Gable, as the perpetrator, according to a report by Breitbart News.

Judith's body was discovered by a building manager searching for unpaid rent, while her 20-month-old son was found safe in another room. An autopsy confirmed she died from homicidal strangulation, with evidence of a violent struggle and sexual assault at the scene.

Uncovering a Long-Hidden Truth in Concord

Hairs on Judith's body and a damp towel with seminal fluid pointed to a brutal crime, leading investigators to suspect Gable, a 24-year-old neighbor. Fingerprints and witness accounts, including Judith's own fears about Gable, further tightened the focus on him.

Yet, a flawed FBI forensic report from 1975 derailed the case, wrongly concluding that Gable couldn't have contributed the hairs found at the scene. This error allowed a dangerous man to walk free for years, evading accountability while a family grieved without answers.

Attorney General John Formella noted, "the case was severely hindered by a flawed forensic report issued by the FBI in 1975." Such missteps highlight how fragile justice can be when bureaucracy fumbles, leaving victims like Judith without a voice for decades.

Disturbing Details of Fear and Betrayal

Judith had confided in her sister about her unease, specifically naming Gable as someone who unnerved her with inappropriate comments. The report quotes her saying he "had made remarks to her about wanting to see her nude," a chilling prelude to the violence that followed.

Witnesses later recalled Gable knocking on her door at 2 a.m., asking if she would "party with him" while his wife was away. This brazen behavior, coupled with her expressed fear, paints a picture of a predator circling a vulnerable young mother.

Judith had moved into the apartment with her husband, Gregory, and their three sons after returning from Germany, only for Gregory to assault her just 16 days before her murder. Though initially a suspect, Gregory was cleared after family members confirmed his alibi, shifting attention to the true culprit next door.

Justice Delayed but Not Denied

Gable escaped prosecution for Judith's murder, living on until 1987 when he was stabbed to death in Los Angeles. His violent end, while unrelated, closes a dark chapter for a man who inflicted so much pain on an innocent family.

Formella expressed hope for healing, stating, "It is my hope that this long-awaited conclusion will finally bring peace and closure to Judy Lord’s family and the entire Concord community after nearly five decades of delayed justice." His words carry weight, acknowledging the endurance of those who never stopped seeking the truth.

The resolution of this case also sends a broader message about the dogged pursuit of facts, no matter how much time has passed. As Formella added, "This resolution proves that no cold case is ever truly closed until the truth is found," a reminder that justice, though slow, can still prevail.

A Community Reflects on a Painful Past

For Concord, this isn't just about solving a crime; it's about reclaiming a sense of safety and trust that was shattered in 1975. Judith's story, and that of her young son left behind, lingered as a wound in the community's memory, now finally addressed.

The systemic failures of the past, like that flawed FBI report, stand as a cautionary tale against over-reliance on imperfect tools when human lives hang in the balance. We must demand better from our institutions, ensuring they serve victims rather than shield the guilty through error or oversight.

As we reflect on Judith Lord's tragic fate, there's a quiet resolve to honor her by learning from history. Her family, robbed of so much, can at least hold onto the certainty of who took her from them, even if the reckoning came too late for the courtroom.

Most Recent Stories

Copyright 2024, Thin Line News LLC