Shackled inmate spits on Florida judge during wild courtroom outburst

 September 15, 2025

A chaotic scene unfolded in a Florida courtroom when a shackled inmate launched an aggressive attack during his status hearing.

According to the New York Post, Evan Paul McCulloch, 46, managed to spit on Judge William L. Roby and attempted to storm the bench before being subdued by security personnel. The incident occurred during a Wednesday hearing at the Martin County Courthouse, where McCulloch was already classified as a special status inmate due to his history of threatening judges.

The defendant entered the courtroom in full restraints, with shackles securing his wrists, ankles, and midsection. Despite these precautions, McCulloch's violent tendencies emerged within moments of approaching the podium.

Long History of Violence Precedes Attack

McCulloch's criminal record dates back to 2023, with multiple stays at Martin County Jail. His legal proceedings have faced numerous delays due to competency concerns related to his mental health conditions.

Court officials had previously deemed McCulloch incompetent to stand trial because of various mental illnesses. The defendant was recently cleared for transfer to a state hospital but remained in custody pending further evaluation.

While incarcerated, McCulloch demonstrated a pattern of aggressive behavior toward law enforcement. He reportedly assaulted several deputies and caused multiple disturbances within the facility.

Security Response Prevents Further Violence

Six deputies immediately responded when McCulloch began his aggressive display. Their swift action prevented the situation from escalating into a more serious incident.

The security footage captured the dramatic moment when McCulloch knocked over the podium and attempted to reach the judge. The team of deputies quickly tackled and restrained the defendant before he could cause additional harm.

Two other inmates present in the courtroom remained remarkably calm during the incident. They watched without visible reaction as the chaotic scene unfolded before them.

Judge Maintains Composure Despite Attack

Judge Roby demonstrated remarkable professionalism throughout the ordeal. Despite being spat upon by the defendant, he maintained his composure and continued with the court's schedule.

The hearing was immediately suspended following McCulloch's outburst. Deputies safely removed the defendant from the courtroom to prevent any further disruptions.

McCulloch now faces additional felony charges for his actions during the hearing. The incident could result in significant prison time being added to any existing sentences.

Implications for Future Court Proceedings

The violent outburst raises serious questions about courthouse security protocols for high-risk inmates. McCulloch's previous threats against judges had already earned him a special status classification.

This incident highlights the ongoing challenges of managing mentally ill defendants within the justice system. The balance between providing necessary medical care and maintaining courtroom safety remains a critical concern.

The case has been temporarily suspended while authorities review security measures and determine how to proceed with McCulloch's pending legal matters. His transfer to a state hospital may now face additional scrutiny given this latest violent episode.

Most Recent Stories

Copyright 2024, Thin Line News LLC